Bitcoin (BTC) continues to dominate the financial headlines, especially with the explosive success of spot Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs) in the United States. Despite unprecedented institutional demand and what some have called the "most successful product launch in history," BTC has failed to launch into stratospheric price territory—what many in the crypto community refer to as "going to the moon."
Fundstrat Global Advisors co-founder and Chief Investment Officer Tom Lee recently offered insight into why Bitcoin’s price may be stagnating despite strong ETF inflows. According to Lee, two critical market dynamics are currently acting as counterweights to bullish momentum.
Why ETF Demand Isn’t Pushing Bitcoin Prices Higher
The launch of spot Bitcoin ETFs in January 2024 marked a turning point for crypto adoption. These funds have attracted over $48.6 billion in net inflows** within months, signaling robust institutional interest. Yet Bitcoin’s price hovers around **$107,290—a level it previously reached in late 2024—suggesting that demand isn’t translating directly into upward price pressure.
Tom Lee identifies a structural reason behind this phenomenon: in-kind contributions.
👉 Discover how ETF mechanics could reshape crypto investing in 2025.
Many investors are not buying Bitcoin on the open market to contribute to ETFs. Instead, they’re depositing existing BTC holdings directly into ETF structures through in-kind transfers. This means no new buy-side pressure is added to the market because the ETF providers aren’t purchasing additional Bitcoin—they’re simply accepting digital assets investors already own.
“A lot of these ETFs may have been receiving in-kind exchange. So people have their crypto keys, give it to the ETF provider and then they just stepped up their basis. So that’s not going to push up the price of Bitcoin,” Lee explained in a recent CNBC interview.
This nuance is crucial for understanding market dynamics. While ETFs are absorbing supply, they’re doing so without generating fresh demand through open-market purchases—limiting their immediate impact on price appreciation.
Profit-Taking by Long-Term Holders: A Hidden Downward Pressure
The second factor Lee highlights is profit realization among early Bitcoin adopters.
A significant portion of Bitcoin’s supply is held by long-term investors who bought at prices ranging from a few dollars to a few thousand. With BTC trading near $107,000, many of these holders are sitting on life-changing gains. For them, current prices represent a compelling opportunity to cash out—even if they believe Bitcoin could eventually reach $1 million.
“The ones who aren’t involved in ETFs, but maybe they have $10-Bitcoin… we have clients that have bought Bitcoin at $100 and now it’s $100,000. They don’t care if Bitcoin goes to $1 million. They are probably sellers at around $100,000,” Lee noted.
This creates a churn effect: as new investors enter via ETFs, early holders exit through direct sales or in-kind contributions. The result is a balancing act where new demand is offset by old supply hitting the market.
This dynamic explains why Bitcoin’s price hasn’t surged despite strong ETF inflows—it’s not a lack of interest, but rather a redistribution of ownership from early believers to institutional players.
Core Market Implications
The interplay between ETF accumulation and long-term holder behavior reveals deeper truths about Bitcoin’s maturation:
- Market depth is increasing, but price volatility is being tempered by structural factors.
- Institutional adoption is real, but it’s happening through mechanisms that don’t always stimulate immediate price growth.
- Retail and early investor behavior remains a powerful influence on short-term price action.
Bitcoin’s journey from speculative asset to institutional staple is underway—but it’s not a straight line upward.
👉 See how next-gen trading platforms are adapting to evolving crypto markets.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: Do Bitcoin ETFs always buy BTC on the open market?
A: No. While some ETFs make open-market purchases, many accept in-kind contributions—meaning investors transfer existing BTC holdings directly to the fund without triggering new buys.
Q: How do in-kind transfers affect Bitcoin’s price?
A: They limit immediate upward price pressure because no new demand is created. The Bitcoin simply changes hands from private wallets into ETF custodial accounts.
Q: Why are long-term holders selling now?
A: Many early investors bought BTC for less than $1,000. At prices above $100,000, they’re realizing massive gains. Even if they believe in Bitcoin’s long-term potential, taking profits at this stage is a rational financial decision.
Q: Could Bitcoin still surge despite these factors?
A: Absolutely. Once the churn between old and new ownership stabilizes, and if ETFs begin relying more on open-market purchases, renewed bullish momentum could emerge—especially with macro tailwinds like monetary easing or increased regulatory clarity.
Q: What would trigger more open-market buying by ETFs?
A: If investor demand outpaces the availability of existing BTC for in-kind transfers, ETF providers will be forced to buy on exchanges—directly increasing market demand.
Q: Is this price stagnation a sign of weakness?
A: Not necessarily. Consolidation after rapid gains is normal in maturing markets. This phase may be laying the foundation for broader institutional ownership and more sustainable long-term growth.
The Road Ahead for Bitcoin
While Bitcoin hasn’t “gone to the moon” yet, its integration into traditional finance continues at a historic pace. The current equilibrium—where massive ETF inflows are balanced by profit-taking—may be exactly what’s needed for a more stable and resilient market.
As 95% of institutional investors still remain on the sidelines, the potential for future demand remains enormous. When the churn subsides and new capital begins flowing through open-market purchases, the next leg of Bitcoin’s journey could truly begin.
👉 Explore how global investors are positioning for the next crypto cycle.
Core Keywords: Bitcoin ETF, Tom Lee, in-kind contributions, profit-taking, long-term holders, ETF inflows, Bitcoin price analysis, crypto market dynamics