Leveraged ETFs have long been a topic of controversy in the investment world. Market newcomers often misunderstand their mechanics, while seasoned investors debate whether these instruments belong in a long-term portfolio. On the surface, leveraged ETFs promise amplified returns—2x or even 3x the daily performance of an underlying index or stock. But what happens when you hold them for months or years? Are they ticking time bombs, or misunderstood tools with hidden potential?
Let’s break down how leveraged ETFs work, why their long-term behavior defies intuition, and whether holding them might actually make sense under specific conditions.
How Do Leveraged ETFs Work?
Leveraged Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) are designed to deliver multiples of the daily return of a benchmark—such as the S&P 500, Nasdaq-100, or even individual stocks like Tesla or MicroStrategy. For example, a 3x leveraged ETF aims to return three times the index’s gain (or loss) each trading day.
Crucially, this leverage resets every day. That means the fund rebalances its exposure at the end of each session to maintain the targeted multiple. This daily reset is the root cause of what many call “volatility decay” or “compounding drag”—phenomena that can cause long-term returns to diverge sharply from simple multiples of the underlying asset’s performance.
👉 Discover how leveraged instruments behave over time—explore market dynamics now.
Consider this: if the S&P 500 rises 1% one day and falls 1% the next, it ends slightly lower due to compounding math. A 3x leveraged version would gain 3% then lose 3.09%, resulting in a net loss—even though the index barely moved. Over time, this effect can erode value, especially in choppy markets.
But does that mean leveraged ETFs always fail over the long term? Not necessarily.
The Myth of Inevitable Decay
It's true that leveraged ETFs suffer from volatility drag, which stems from two main factors:
- Path Dependency and Compounding Losses: A 50% drop requires a 100% gain just to break even. Now imagine a 3x ETF: a 30% market decline translates into a devastating 90% plunge in the ETF. To recover, it would need a staggering 1,000% return. This asymmetry makes recovery extremely difficult after large drawdowns.
- Rebalancing Mechanism: Leveraged ETFs use derivatives or borrowing to maintain their exposure. When prices rise, they buy more; when prices fall, they sell—essentially "buying high and selling low." This mechanical process amplifies losses during volatile periods.
Despite these drawbacks, critics often overlook one key fact: in consistently rising markets, leveraged ETFs can outperform dramatically over time.
A study highlighted by Christian Knapp of Bosun Asset Management shows that SSO, a 2x S&P 500 ETF, delivered a cumulative return of 404% between June 2006 and December 2022—nearly double the 209% return of its unleveraged counterpart, SPY.
Even more compelling is a backtest conducted by a financial content creator known as “Wall Street Millennial,” who simulated a theoretical 3x S&P 500 ETF dating back to 1927. Using dollar-cost averaging—investing $100 annually—the hypothetical portfolio grew to **$13 million, compared to less than $500,000** in a standard index fund.
This staggering difference underscores a powerful truth: persistent upward trends can overcome volatility drag—especially when combined with disciplined, long-term investing strategies.
Can You Really Buy and Hold Leveraged ETFs?
The answer isn't black and white. While traditional wisdom warns against holding leveraged ETFs beyond a single trading session, data suggests they can generate exceptional returns—if certain conditions are met:
- The underlying asset exhibits a strong long-term uptrend (e.g., broad market indices).
- Investors use dollar-cost averaging, reducing timing risk.
- Holdings represent only a small portion of the overall portfolio.
However, there’s a catch: performance is highly sensitive to entry points. Investing a lump sum just before a major crash—like the Great Depression or the 2008 financial crisis—could result in near-total loss with a 3x ETF.
Moreover, leveraged ETFs tracking individual stocks (such as MicroStrategy or Tesla) are far riskier than those tied to diversified indices. One such product, GraniteShares' LMI3 (3x MicroStrategy), dropped nearly 82% in a year—even as MicroStrategy stock itself gained over 100%. This paradox illustrates how daily resets magnify volatility in erratic single-name securities.
👉 See how market momentum impacts leveraged products—analyze real-world outcomes today.
Behavioral Risks: Can You Handle the Ride?
Even if the math works in your favor, the real challenge may be psychological.
Dalbar Research found that over a 20-year period where the S&P 500 returned about 10% annually, the average investor earned only 4%—largely due to poor timing decisions driven by fear and greed.
Now imagine holding a 3x ETF during a market downturn. A 10% drop in the index becomes a 30%+ plunge in your fund. For most people, that kind of volatility triggers panic selling—locking in losses and defeating the purpose of long-term investing.
As one Reddit user aptly put it:
“People sell at -50% on unleveraged funds. Holding 2x or 3x through such a year feels endless. Emotional resilience is underestimated.”
This behavioral hurdle makes leveraged ETFs unsuitable for most retail investors—even if the historical data looks promising.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: What exactly is a leveraged ETF?
A: A leveraged ETF uses financial derivatives and debt to amplify the daily returns of an underlying index or asset—typically offering 2x or 3x exposure.
Q: Why don’t leveraged ETFs perform as expected over time?
A: Due to daily rebalancing and compounding effects, their returns diverge from simple multiples of the underlying asset’s long-term performance—especially in volatile or sideways markets.
Q: Can I hold a leveraged ETF for years?
A: While possible, it's risky. Success depends heavily on market direction, timing, and investor psychology. Most issuers warn against long-term holding.
Q: Are all leveraged ETFs the same?
A: No. Those tracking broad indices (like S&P 500) tend to fare better over time than those based on single stocks or volatile sectors.
Q: Do leveraged ETFs pay dividends?
A: Some do, but distributions are typically reinvested automatically and may not reflect the underlying index’s yield due to leverage costs.
Q: Is now a good time to invest in leveraged ETFs?
A: It depends on your risk tolerance, investment horizon, and market outlook. In strong bull markets, they may enhance returns—but require careful monitoring.
Final Thoughts: A Tool, Not a Strategy
Leveraged ETFs aren't inherently bad—they're just misunderstood. Designed for short-term traders, they can deliver extraordinary results over decades if the market climbs steadily and investors stay disciplined.
But let’s be clear: they are not “set-and-forget” investments. They demand deep understanding, emotional fortitude, and strict risk management.
For most investors, allocating even a small portion of “fun money” to leveraged ETFs should come with full awareness of the risks. And never consider them as core holdings.
Ultimately, leveraged ETFs reflect broader truths about investing: returns come with volatility, compounding works both ways—and staying rational in turbulent markets is half the battle.
👉 Test your risk tolerance and explore advanced investment tools—start learning today.